Not In Our Name
A simple way to strengthen our democracy8th December 2019
Boris Johnson’s decision to prorogue Parliament exposed a simple fact: our democracy is not fit for purpose. Not only does the government of the day enjoy sweeping powers over Parliament, but when it comes to what Britain does internationally our democracy has very little control over what’s done in our name.
That’s why we’ve launched the Not In Our Name principle.
It’s based on three simple steps. First, end the extreme secrecy in what position UK negotiators take internationally. Second, give Parliament the right to mandate British the government to take particular positions in international negotiations. Third, give Parliament the right to a final say on signing international treaties.
Here’s why it matters.
Parliament is sovereign in the UK, right?
Yes, but… Once a government is elected and can command a majority in Parliament it has sweeping power over our democracy. That’s why Lord Hailsham famously said in the 1970s it amounted to an elective dictatorship: ‘the government controls Parliament and not Parliament the government’.
But can’t Parliament still hold them to account?
In lots of areas, Parliament still enjoys lots of power to scrutinise, check and balance what the government does. But foreign policy, including the ratification of international treaties, is different. What the British government does and says in foreign affairs takes place under the royal prerogative or the ‘Crown in Parliament’.
Why does it matter?
This system was not as much of a problem in an era when international politics played little role in domestic politics. But today more and more of what happens in domestic politics is affected by international treaties and agreements. Trade deals, in particular, have a major affect on UK domestic law, as do European rules and treaties.
What’s this got to do with Donald Trump?
If Britain leaves the EU and signs a trade deal with Donald Trump’s America it will lead to the marketization and selloff of our NHS. As it stands, Parliament does not even have the right to vote on whether to sign Trump’s deal or not. The government could just sign it and Parliament would have to accept it.
What are the 3 big problems with the status quo?
1. Secrecy. As diplomacy is traditionally done away from prying eyes, rules that could transform our NHS are negotiated in secrecy with zero transparency.
2. No mandate. Parliament cannot vote to mandate the government to take a particulate position in international negotiation. Our democracy just has to accept whatever government comes up with.
3. No final say. Worse still even international treaties that massively affect things like the NHS can be signed by the government without Parliament having the right to a final say. There’s no requirement to ratify them.
How does this relate to the EU?
EU rules automatically become law for EU members. The British government puts forward its position in European institutions ‘in our name’. But Parliament has no power to mandate the government to take particular positions. This has fed the mistaken idea that European rules are things ‘done to us’ and not things Britain has shaped. In fact, the opposite is true. Britain has for decades successfully used its influence to move the EU in the wrong direction towards more cuts and privatisation. But Parliament only has a very limited right to scrutinise and shape these decisions.
So what’s the Not In Our Name principle?
It’s a simple way to strengthen our democracy. It would:
• Introduce full transparency over negotiations
• Give Parliament the power to mandate a particular position in international treaty negotiations
• Give Parliament the right to a final say on an international treaty
• Establish a special procedure for how Britain relates to the European institutions
Report: Don't accept this terrible Brexit deal, the case for reform
Another Europe Is Possible launches major new report setting out a series of fundamental problems with the UK-EU Brexit deal Read more »
Two motions for Labour conference 2021
This year, Another Europe is urging its supporters in Labour to put forward two vital motions - on migrants' rights and electoral reform. Read more »
Holyrood candidates pledge not to cooperate with Tories’ post-Brexit border regime
Major figures in Scotland have pledged to use the powers of the Scottish parliament to fight back against Westminster's anti-migrant agenda. Read our press release here. Read more »
The problem is vaccine monopolies
The latest diplomatic row between the UK and EU is a distraction from the real issue - the prioritisation of profit over human life and good sense. Read more »
Report: Right to Stay, but how to prove it?
We are now just months away from the June 30th application deadline and it's clear that Settled Status is not working. Read our new report. Read more »