What went wrong? Hundreds join conversation at Brexit Britain event
Last Saturday around 450 people attended, ‘Brexit Britain: What went wrong and what next?’, at the London School of Economics10th October 2016
The EU referendum result was a big blow to the left – in Britain and across Europe. From trade unions to progressive political parties and social movement activists, the left overwhelmingly argued for a critical remain case.
Saturday’s event was one of the first opportunities the left has had to regroup, discuss what went wrong, and decide what steps we should take as the negotiations and conflicts over Britain’s position within Europe begin.
Co-organised by Another Europe Is Possible, Open Democracy, the Democracy in Europe Movement 2025, and the LSE Human Security and Civil Society Research Unit, Brexit Britain brought together academics, political figures and campaigners from across the progressive movement.
Opening the event, Mary Kaldor, Professor of Global Governance at the LSE, noted how ‘we have found that “take back control” means handing power to an extreme right wing cabal’. Stressing the importance of the event, she would be one of many contributors expressing ‘alarm at the speed at which this tragedy is unfolding’.
While there was an energy and buzz in the room, the event was above all else an opportunity for careful reflection over rhetoric. Owen Jones urged participants to be nuanced in how they discussed the relationship between class and the Leave vote, noting, for example, the significant variation between the different towns and cities of the UK. Most of all, he argued, ‘it is a failure of the left that many working class people look at service cuts, job insecurity and housing through the lens of immigration’.
Ash Sarkar, of Novara Media, argued we must ‘look beyond the spectacle of fear – of saying how terrible everything is – and on to political analysis’ of the situation. While Yanis Varoufakis of the Democracy in Europe Movement similarly said, ‘we must grasp the constituents of our failure and not blame anyone else’.
This sense of criticism and reflection was the overarching theme of the day. But the event was also about more than reflection and ideas.
The closing session provided an opportunity for agreeing practical steps forward.
A declaration was agreed after a process of amendment committing Another Europe Is Possible to a series of progressive campaigning priorities in the Brexit negotiations, and to work towards an agreement to join forces with the Democracy in Europe Movement.
The declaration also reflected the results of a recent online consultation of Another Europe Is Possible supporters which had seen over 1,300 people participate.
There was also a general feeling that more time for discussion and agreement of policy was needed with a further conference called in January.
It will be preceded by local and regional participatory forums across the UK to feed into the final conference.
1. Declaration of Brexit Britain event
8 October 2016, London School of Economics
During the EU referendum, we brought together thousands of people all over Britain across and beyond party lines in order to campaign for a progressive Remain vote. Now, we have a duty to provide continued opposition to Tory Brexit.
In the immediate term, that means demanding a democratic process, including recognising that Scotland and Northern Ireland voted remain, and demanding transparency in the Brexit negotiations. The British people have the right to know what their government is saying and negotiating. And it means demanding that any triggering of Article 50 is subject to proper democratic scrutiny.
Our aims and principles
Our broader aims are now what they were during the campaign. We stand for a society run in the interests of people and the planet. We stand for an open society and a pluralist politics.
The legal protections for the environment, workers, migrants and human rights provided by EU membership were limited, but on many levels they were vital, and they were the beginning of something better. We will campaign to retain and extend all of these hard won protections.
We will also campaign to protect science, research and higher education, campaigning for Britain to ‘buy in’ to EU research budgets, to protect the right of the next generation to study at European institutions, and keep our own universities open to students from Europe.
We stand unequivocally for continued and improved freedom of movement, and we will campaign for the rights of migrants and refugees at a time of growing domestic prejudice and international crisis.
We are for solidarity between people and across borders. The struggle to win gains for ordinary people, and to democratise the European project, is our struggle – regardless of the outcome of the Brexit negotiations.
What outcome are we campaigning for?
Throughout the Brexit negotiations, we will argue for outcomes in line with these aims and principles – and we will do so in the spirit of democracy, accepting the result of the referendum but not giving up on our pro-European and internationalist values and aims.
In this spirit, we will demand that in determining what Brexit really means, the people – not Theresa May’s administration – must have the defining say. We stand firm in our demand of a democratic debate and decision making which allows the the peoples of England, Northern Ireland and Wales (whether they be Leavers or Remainers) to participate fully, directly, or through their representatives, in the shaping of our destiny.
How we organise
We will organise our campaign on a broad basis, welcoming all stripes of progressive forces across political parties, ideologies and conceptions of a good society.
Now that the referendum is over, we must commit our organisation to greater internal democracy – to include more people from the grassroots in the core organising, and to consult all of our supporters about what we do.
Another Europe Is Possible will seek to join forces with the Democracy in Europe Movement 2025 (DiEM25) on terms that enhance our capacity to demonstrate to the people of Britain that another Britain is indeed possible as long as European democrats reach out across national and organisational borders in search of shared democracy and shared prosperity.
2. Other proposals passed by Brexit Britain event
a. Another Europe is Possible calls for solidarity with refugees and asylum seekers, and with the frontline countries like Greece which lack resources to cope. All European states, including the UK, must co-operate to end the scandal of squalid camps and offer proper resettlement for refugees, with contributions proportionate to national GDP.
b. Another Europe is Possible will seek to democratise itself and to give structure to its grassroots support. In the coming months, we will launch a review, consulting supporters and stakeholders, on our processes, structures, name, infrastructure and organisational form. This will conclude at a democratic event in early 2017.
3. Other proposals not passed by Brexit Britain event
These other proposals were referred (due to lack of time) for further discussion in the run up to the next decision making meeting in January.
a. If the government chooses to privilege the England and Wales Leave votes over the Scotland and Northern Ireland Remain votes, they risk a breakup of the UK and destabilisation in Ireland. A Greenland-style treaty could prevent this by respecting each country’s decision in the referendum.
b. First campaign priority must be to ensure that HM Government does not make a formal declaration of the UK’s intent to withdraw from the EU without the prior-given express authority of Parliament, and that HMG makes clear its proposed ‘terms of exit’ before seeking such authority.
c. Second campaign priority must be to itemise all the Regulations made under Statutory Instruments to implement EU Directives, where the power to act derives from the European Communities Act 1972, and which will have no legal effect once the UK ceases to be a member of the EU.
The real nightmare before Christmas: a US trade deal in the middle of Covid
How and why you should join the day of action against the US trade deal. Read more »
We will fight for every inch
A statement from the National Committee of Another Europe: The left and the remains of the anti-Brexit movement must break their silence and mobilise against the Tories' Brexit agenda. Read more »
Opposition parties call on government to introduce ‘right to stay’ for EU citizens
Representatives of the SNP, the Lib Dems, Plaid Cymru, the Green Party and the SDLP have today written to the Prime Minister urging him to take fresh measures to protect the rights of European citizens after Brexit. Read more »
Event: No going back to ‘normal’, 14th September 2020
The global economy, pandemic politics and system transformation in the 21st century, with Joseph Stiglitz and Mary Kaldor. 3–4.15pm UK time, 14th September 2020 Read more »
Key left figures launch ‘Alternative Mandate’ for Brexit negotiations
Left and progressives to unite around demands on the Brexit process, warning of "shock doctrine" moment if Tory plans are allowed to go ahead. Read more »